Welcome to NateDSanders.com

Hollywood Memorabilia, Fine Autographs, & Consignments Blog

Nate D. Sanders Super Bowl Trophy Auction Presents the Super Bowl Trophy Price Guide

To buy, consign or sell in our Super Bowl trophy auction, please email Nate at Nate@NateDSanders.com or phone (310) 440-2982.  Thank you.

Super Bowl trophy auction

When John Matuszak’s sister called me and then three-time Dallas Cowboys champion, the now deceased, Godfrey Myles, called me to sell their Super Bowl trophy in my Super Bowl trophy auction, I thought that we might do okay.  Little did I realize that the Matuszak family did great, but Godfrey Myles Super Bowl trophies sold for a fortune — almost $50,000 for all three.  Please see below for all of the Super Bowl trophy auction events I have had and their prices realized:

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXX Trophy — Exceedingly Rare Trophy Was Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams — Given to Cowboys Linebacker Godfrey Myles

Stunning, impressive Vince Lombardi Super Bowl trophy from Super Bowl XXX, won by the Dallas Cowboys in 1996 and given to Coyboys linebacker Godfrey Myles. An almost exact replica of the Vince Lombardi trophy manufactured by Tiffany’s and presented to the winning Super Bowl team, this silver-plated trophy was ordered by Cowboys owner Jerry Jones for his players. Since only a few owners have purchased these trophies, beginning with Al Davis of the Oakland Raiders in 1977, they remain notoriously scarce and desirable, with only a handful coming to auction in the past 30 years. Trophy measures approximately 15.5″ high and 7″ deep and weighs 6.0 lbs. Upon the front is engraved, “Vince Lombardi Trophy / Super Bowl / XXX / Champions / The Dallas Cowboys” and, along the side column, “Godfrey Myles / 98”. Good condition with minor chipping. A stunning display of athletic achievement, from the team that sets the record for most Super Bowl appearances. With Certificate of Authenticity from Godfrey Myles.  Sold for $17,400.

Super Bowl trophy auction Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXX Trophy -- Exceedingly Rare Trophy Was Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams -- Given to Cowboys Linebacker Godfrey Myles

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXX Trophy — Exceedingly Rare Trophy Was Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams — Given to Cowboys Linebacker Godfrey Myles

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXVIII Trophy — Given to Dallas Cowboys Linebacker Godfrey Myles

Stunning, impressive Vince Lombardi Super Bowl trophy from Super Bowl XXVIII , won by the Dallas Cowboys in 1994. An almost exact replica of the Vince Lombardi trophy manufactured by Tiffany’s and presented to the winning Super Bowl team, this silver-plated trophy was ordered by Cowboys owner Jerry Jones for his players. Since only a few owners have purchased these trophies, beginning with Al Davis of the Oakland Raiders in 1977, they remain notoriously scarce and desirable, with only a handful coming to auction in the past 30 years. Trophy measures approximately 15.5″ high and 7″ deep and weighs 10.8 lbs. Upon the front is engraved, “Vince Lombardi Trophy / Super Bowl / XXVIII / Champions / The Dallas Cowboys” and, on the side column, “Godfrey Myles / 98 [Myles player number]”. Good condition with isolated chipping to the silver, especially on the football that sits atop the triangular column. A stunning display of athletic achievement, from the team that sets the record for most Super Bowl appearances. With Certificate of Authenticity from Godfrey Myles. Sold for $17,400.

Super Bowl trophy auction Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXVIII Trophy -- Given to Dallas Cowboys Linebacker Godfrey Myles

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXVIII Trophy — Given to Dallas Cowboys Linebacker Godfrey Myles

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXVII Trophy — Exceedingly Rare Trophy Was Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams

Stunning, impressive Vince Lombardi Super Bowl trophy from Super Bowl XXVII given to Dallas Cowboy linebacker Godfrey Myles. An almost exact replica of the Vince Lombardi trophy manufactured by Tiffany’s and presented to the winning Super Bowl team, this silver-plated trophy was ordered by Cowboys owner Jerry Jones for his players. Since only a few owners have purchased these trophies, beginning with Al Davis of the Oakland Raiders in 1977, they remain notoriously scarce and desirable, with only a handful coming to auction in the past 30 years. Trophy measures approximately 15.5″ high and 7″ deep and weighs 7.6 lbs. Upon the front is engraved, “Vince Lombardi Trophy / Super Bowl / XXVII / Champions / The Dallas Cowboys” and, on the bottom of a side column, “Godfrey Myles / 98”. Good condition with minor chipping. A stunning display of athletic achievement, from the team that sets the record for most Super Bowl appearances. With Certificate of Authenticity from Godfrey Myles.  Sold for $16,861.

Super Bowl trophy auction Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXVII Trophy -- Exceedingly Rare Trophy Was Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XXVII Trophy — Exceedingly Rare Trophy Was Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams

John Matuszak’s Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XI Trophy — Exceedingly Rare Trophy Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams

Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XI trophy given to defensive lineman John Matuszak of the Oakland Raiders, for their first Super Bowl win in 1977 against the Minnesota Vikings. Silver-plated trophy was ordered by Raiders owner Al Davis for each of his players, the first time Vince Lombardi replica trophies had been given to individual team members. A small handful of owners have since followed Davis’ example, making these player trophies exceedingly rare, even more so one owned by standout player John Matuszak. This trophy made by R.S. Owens & Co. is the three-quartered size version of the Tiffany made Vince Lombardi trophy (the larger of the two), and measures 18″ tall, situated on a triangular base measuring about 9″ on each side. Engraved upon the column reads, “Vince Lombardi Trophy / [NFL logo] / Super Bowl XI / AFC vs NFC”. Upon the base is an engraved silver plate which reads, “The Oakland Raiders / World Champions / John Matuszak / Oakland 32 – Minnesota 14 / January 9, 1977”. In very good condition with only some cleaning needed to the silver plating. Trophy accompanied by certificate of authenticity by Matuszak’s sister. An impressive tribute to John Matuszak and the Oakland Raiders.  Sold for $9,975.

Super Bowl trophy auction John Matuszak's Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XI Trophy -- Exceedingly Rare Trophy Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams

John Matuszak’s Vince Lombardi Super Bowl XI Trophy — Exceedingly Rare Trophy Made for Players of Only a Few Super Bowl Winning Teams

St. Louis Rams Super Bowl XXXIV Trophy From 2000 — One of 400 Given to Players, Executives & Team Employees

St. Louis Rams Super Bowl trophy from Super Bowl XXXIV. In one of the most classic Super Bowls of all time, the St. Louis Rams beat the Tennessee Titans 23-16, a game which ended with Tennessee receiver Kevin Dyson landing one yard short of scoring the game-tying touchdown as time ran out. Replica of iconic Vince Lombardi trophy is one of 400 trophies given to players, team executives and employees. Sterling silver trophy contains “Vince Lombardi Trophy / Super Bowl XXXIV Champions / The St. Louis Rams” engraved to front, with “Randy Wedel” and “172 out of 400″ engraved to verso at the base. Measures 17″ tall and 5” across the base. Weighs 7 lbs. 14 oz. Tarnishing and slight discoloration at the base, overall very good to near fine condition.   Sold for $2,682.

Super Bowl trophy auction St. Louis Rams Super Bowl XXXIV Trophy From 2000 -- One of 400 Given to Players, Executives & Team Employees

St. Louis Rams Super Bowl XXXIV Trophy From 2000 — One of 400 Given to Players, Executives & Team Employees

To buy, consign or sell in our Super Bowl trophy auction, please email Nate at Nate@NateDSanders.com or phone (310) 440-2982.  Thank you.

Comments are closed

This site is protected by Comment SPAM Wiper.
Copyright 2016 © Nate D. Sanders, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement